Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced Wiki

Collectibles / Secrets

Crooked Island Secrets — My First Reverie & German Rapiers

First move

Check My First Reverie and German Rapiers by name in the current save, then use the live Crooked Island Secret markers for only the missing beach or cliff result.

Type
Two Secret pickups
Area
Crooked Island
Location
Beach letter and cliff-rock sword
Reward
My First Reverie letter; German Rapiers (Common Sword)
Last updated October 3, 2026 Two Secret pickups Confirm in current build

Crooked Island · two-Secret diagnosis

A beach chest can be open while the missing Secret is still on the cliff

This old URL was labelled a manuscript, but the current guide lead names two different Secrets: the My First Reverie letter on a beach section and German Rapiers along cliff rocks. Start from the missing name in your save, then choose one surface; the guarded beach money chest has its own counter.

  1. Read the 1/2 gap first

    Do this

    Open Crooked Island's current Secret state and compare the named letter and sword in your collection. A missing letter sends you to a beach Secret; a missing sword sends you toward the cliff rocks. Do not infer the answer from an old manuscript search result.

    Check the local Secret family
    Look for

    You have identified which named result is absent before crossing the island again.

    If it does not work

    If the counter and inventory disagree, write down both states and the current build. Continue with the live Secret marker but do not mark a reward owned from a vanished icon alone.

  2. Beach · My First Reverie

    Do this

    Follow the live Secret icon to the relevant beach section and inspect the letter pickup. The ordinary beach money chest is guarded and may be nearby, but it is a different activity; assess the present guards only if that separate chest is your target.

    Compare beach marker types
    Look for

    My First Reverie is recorded as a letter, not merely Reales or one ordinary chest opened.

    If it does not work

    If the beach pickup yields money, preserve that chest result and recheck the Secret icon. If the letter is already in the collection, leave this surface and focus on the cliff sword.

  3. Cliff rocks · German Rapiers

    Do this

    Use the current cliff-side Secret marker and visible safe footing to reach the pickup among rocks. The source does not establish an exact coordinate, cliff face or reliable jump sequence, so choose the approach from the terrain in your build.

    Prepare the visible approach
    Look for

    German Rapiers appears by name as a Common Sword and the island's two-Secret state agrees with the letter result.

    If it does not work

    If you cannot reach the icon safely, return to a visible approach instead of forcing an unverified drop. If a pickup gives money, recheck its family and the sword collection before leaving.

Use the reward name to avoid a second full-island sweep

Letter SecretMy First Reverie on a beach section.The named letter is the proof; a beach money chest cannot replace it.Sword SecretGerman Rapiers along the cliff rocks.Verify the sword by name after the live cliff marker's pickup.Ordinary chestA guarded money chest also sits on the beach.Its opening belongs to the chest family, not the 2/2 Secret result.

Before you leaveLeave when My First Reverie, German Rapiers and Crooked Island's Secret count agree in the same save. If only the guarded chest changed, the Secret search remains open.

Research basisResynced Crooked Island regional guideThe regional and all-Secrets pages are one publisher. They give surfaces and rewards, not exact pickup points or a tested cliff climb.

Player workbench

Resolve a Crooked Island 1/2 Secrets result by deciding whether the missing reward is the beach letter or cliff-rock sword.

The historical Manuscript record names no actual manuscript, and the beach also holds a guarded ordinary money chest that can falsely look like the missing Secret.

Why this entry is useful

An inventory-to-landmark diagnostic for two different Secrets, with a wrong-beach-chest branch and named-result proof before a second cliff search.

A Resynced regional guide places the letter on a beach section and the sword along cliff rocks, but does not give exact pickup coordinates or a tested cliff climb. The guide and Secrets list are one publisher, not independent gameplay verification.

Safe first move

Check My First Reverie and German Rapiers by name in the current save, then use the live Crooked Island Secret markers for only the missing beach or cliff result.

Finish line

My First Reverie and German Rapiers are both acquired by name and Crooked Island's two-Secret state agrees; the guarded money chest is recorded independently.

Route picker

What are you trying to do with this entry?

Choose one decision and follow 3 checks in order.

  1. Current markersRead the local Secret count and named letter/sword entries first. If one is already owned, skip its surface and select the unresolved live Secret marker.
  2. Family ledgerFor My First Reverie, inspect the beach Secret. A nearby guarded ordinary money chest is a separate pickup and must not be used as letter proof.
  3. ApproachFor German Rapiers, follow the cliff-rock Secret icon from a safe visible approach and check the sword by name. Reconcile both rewards with the 2/2 state before leaving.
Plan it here, then confirm each marker, objective, reward, or counter in your save.
1 focused entry 4 fact fields 0 coordinate signal Reward-linked
Safe first moveUse the selected route

Start with the first check above and keep the confirmed area, marker, or objective beside the next move.

Risk to avoidProtect the route

The historical Manuscript record names no actual manuscript, and the beach also holds a guarded ordinary money chest that can falsely look like the missing Secret.

Save proofKnow when it worked

My First Reverie and German Rapiers are both acquired by name and Crooked Island's two-Secret state agrees; the guarded money chest is recorded independently.

How to use it

Use the missing name to choose beach or cliff

My First Reverie is a beach letter and German Rapiers is a cliff-rock sword. The guarded money chest is a third result; the old Manuscript label is not a reliable pickup identity.

Recovery path

Crooked Island reads 1/2 Secrets

If the letter is absent, recheck the beach Secret rather than the guarded money chest. If German Rapiers is absent, follow the current cliff-rock Secret marker without assuming a fixed climb. If both names appear but the counter differs, record the current save and patch state; do not claim that a different pickup will fix the mismatch.

Inventory gap → beach or cliff → 2/2 Secret proof

  1. Read the local Secret count and named letter/sword entries first. If one is already owned, skip its surface and select the unresolved live Secret marker.
  2. For My First Reverie, inspect the beach Secret. A nearby guarded ordinary money chest is a separate pickup and must not be used as letter proof.
  3. For German Rapiers, follow the cliff-rock Secret icon from a safe visible approach and check the sword by name. Reconcile both rewards with the 2/2 state before leaving.

Route Plan

Inventory gap → beach or cliff → 2/2 Secret proof

Crooked Island has two reported Secrets: the My First Reverie letter on a section of beach and German Rapiers along the cliff rocks. Check the current Secret markers before choosing an approach; the guarded ordinary money chest on the beach is a different family and does not close a 1/2 Secret result.

  1. Compare My First Reverie and German Rapiers in the current collection before starting another island circuit; identify which of the two Secret results is missing.
  2. Use the live Secret icon for the beach letter or the cliff rocks for the sword. No exact pickup coordinate or fixed cliff climb is established by the current route source.
  3. If a beach pickup gives money, keep the Secret task open. Finish only when both named results and the island's Secret state agree.

If the island reads 1/2

If the island reads 1/2

The useful clue is the missing reward, not which beach icon you last opened. Use the name to make one targeted return.

  • Letter absent: recheck the beach Secret icon and the named My First Reverie result.
  • Sword absent: move to the cliff-rock Secret and plan a visible, safe approach.
  • Both names appear but 1/2 persists: record the save and build before assuming another chest or manuscript exists.

Why the old Manuscript label is wrong

Why the old Manuscript label is wrong

The historical import captured a region-summary snippet rather than a specific manuscript reward. The route now follows two named Secret rewards instead of inventing an extra manuscript.

  • The beach result is a letter; the cliff result is a sword.
  • The guarded money chest has a different icon family and completion signal.
  • Treat the regional 778, 521 label as an island locator, not an exact pickup coordinate.
Animus FragmentsCoordinate-heavy fragment checks.Sea ShantiesSong sheets and chase checks.Templar KeysKey routes and unlock checks.Mayan StelaeStelae and Mayan outfit checks.

Common Questions

What are Crooked Island's two Secrets in Black Flag Resynced?

The two named results are My First Reverie, a beach letter, and German Rapiers, a Common Sword along the cliff rocks. Use the live Secret markers and confirm both names in your save; 778, 521 is the island anchor, not either pickup point.

Why does Crooked Island still say 1/2 after I opened a beach chest?

The beach also has a guarded ordinary money chest. Check whether My First Reverie is in the letter collection and German Rapiers is in the sword collection. If the opened chest only gave money, it did not close either missing Secret.

Are there three Secrets on Crooked Island?

This route covers two named Secret results: My First Reverie on the beach and German Rapiers along the cliff rocks. Check both names in your save; if the current build shows another Secret marker, follow that live marker and keep its result separate until the pickup name and island count explain it.